subscribe: Daily Newsletter


Startups are not creating jobs

1 comment
Startups are not creating jobs

Spotting an opportunity that sparks an entrepreneurial idea is a dominant driver of startup businesses in South Africa – but they are not creating jobs at the scale and rate South Africa so urgently needs.

This is just one of the findings of South Africa’s largest startup survey announced by Seed Academy CEO Donna Rachelson. The survey was conducted this year by Seed Academy when the views of almost 1 500 startup entrepreneurs in South Africa were gauged.

Nearly 50% of the entrepreneurs surveyed said creating a business out of an idea that came to them from the environment in which they live, work and play was their main motivating factor. Only 4% of respondents started a business because they were unable to find a job.

Rachelson says this is a positive sign for South Africa’s entrepreneurial ecosystem as most entrepreneurs are starting businesses for the right reason.

“But only 4% of entrepreneurs surveyed employ more than 10 staff. As many as 38% of startup entrepreneurs do not employ anyone at all. Job creation should be a key outcome of entrepreneurial activity, yet a large portion of our entrepreneurs have no employees.”

The 2016 startup survey built on the benchmarks established in 2015 when Seed Academy conducted the first startup survey to get a picture of the challenges startups face and the support they need to increase success rates.

“This year we sought an understanding of grassroots entrepreneurs, focused in on youth and women entrepreneurs and looked at the challenges faced by entrepreneurs in key sectors. We also gauged the progress made in funding for entrepreneurs,” says Rachelson.

The survey revealed that entrepreneurs are taking long periods to gain traction. Rachelson says it is concerning that there are businesses five years and older that are not making sales.

The survey found that business survival rates are on the increase, female entrepreneurs remain in the minority and that the ethnic footprint of entrepreneurs does not mirror South Africa’s demographics – black startup entrepreneurs are underrepresented.

Rachelson comments: “While the percentage increase in the age of the businesses is small, the fact it is increasing is a step in the right direction. Our entrepreneurs are resilient. They are primarily working from home and funding themselves with small amounts of capital while facing the well-known challenges of finding customers and raising finance.

“The majority of entrepreneurs (59%) are the sole founders of their business. But they are optimistic, especially women business owners.”

The majority of entrepreneurs reported starting businesses in the IT (22%), Creative (12%), Wholesale and Retail (9%) or Social and Community Services (9%) sectors. Mining and Automotive were among the least popular sectors for aspiring entrepreneurs.

A significant outcome was the fact that prior work experience is a major contributing factor in business survival. Business owners that have been in existence for more than two-and-a-half years reported having more than 10 years prior work experience.

Rachelson recommends that entrepreneurs starting a new business may wish to do so in parallel with full time employment.

Furthermore, with 50% of SA’s youth (aged 15-24) currently unemployed, there is a dire shortage of opportunities for them to gain work experience. Innovative ways to provide our young people with work experience need to be found. To develop skills and business acumen, we should be considering interventions such as entrepreneur shadowing or on-the-job training at an SME,” she says.

Rachelson outlines recommendations that all players in the small business ecosystem need to consider:

* Enhancing the funding ecosystem by improving the effectiveness of Development Finance Institutions (DFIs), developing and incentivising the angel network, working with banks and using seed funds;

* Preparing entrepreneurs to be funding-ready;

* Elevating marketing, access to markets and soft skills development for entrepreneurs;

* Fast-tracking and deepening the development of women and youth entrepreneurs;

* Facilitating stronger public/private sector collaborations; and

* More aggressively embedding a culture of entrepreneurship across the country.



  • Anton

    You can’t recklessly create jobs without securing a steady income first. The market is tough and startups need to be sure before creating jobs and/or the need to pay back their investors first. Investors also put a cap on employment and expenses.